Sign in Subscribe

Breakup Pain Isn’t About Your Attachment Style; It’s About How You Cope (New Study)

Last updated on 
Breakup Pain Isn’t About Your Attachment Style; It’s About How You Cope (New Study)
Photo by Kelly Sikkema / Unsplash

When we go through a breakup, many of us immediately jump to attachment theory for answers. “It hurts this much because I’m anxious.” Or, “I feel numb because I’m avoidant.”

But a new longitudinal study published in Emerging Adulthood suggests that your attachment label is not the main thing driving how well you recover. Instead, the biggest predictor of distress is how you cope in the first weeks after the breakup (Gehl et al., 2024)... And that’s actually good news, because coping is something you can change.

Why Labels Don’t Heal

Attachment theory is useful. It gives us a language for patterns like clinginess, withdrawal, or avoidance. But the study found that two people with the same attachment style can have very different recovery outcomes.

What made the difference? Not the label itself, but the coping strategies people used one month after the breakup.

The Study at a Glance

The researchers followed 196 young adults (average age 21) who experienced a romantic breakup. Here’s the design

  • Before the breakup (T1): Measured attachment anxiety and avoidance.
  • One month after (T2): Measured coping strategies.
  • One and three months after (T2 & T3): Measured symptoms of anxiety and depression.

They grouped coping into five “families”:

  1. Self-punishment — self-blame, obsessive replay, rumination.
  2. Accommodation — acceptance, positive reframing, new routines.
  3. Avoidance — denial, disengagement, distraction.
  4. Self-help — emotional expression, support seeking.
  5. Approach — planning, active problem-solving.

The Two Levers That Really Matter

The findings were clear:

  • Self-punishment coping predicted higher depression and anxiety.
  • Accommodation coping predicted lower depression (but not anxiety).

As the authors put it: “Attachment-related anxiety and avoidance were related to more severe depressive and anxiety post-breakup symptoms through (1) a higher use of self-punishment coping and (2) a lower use of accommodation coping”

In simple terms:

  • Beat yourself up → stuck in distress.
  • Accept and reframe → recover faster.

The Anxious Pathway

For anxiously attached individuals, the pain pathway is obvious:

  • Higher anxiety → more self-punishment → higher anxiety & depression at one and three months.
  • They also used less accommodation, which linked to higher depression.

That looks like: “It’s all my fault,” replaying WhatsApp threads, or sending “autopsy texts” at midnight.

Practical reframe: Shift from judge to scientist. Instead of asking “Why am I like this?”, ask “What’s the next helpful action?” — a meal, a walk, a proper night’s sleep.

The Avoidant Pathway

Avoidant individuals looked “fine” at first. But their patterns predicted a delayed crash:

  • Higher avoidance → more self-punishment → higher anxiety at three months.
  • Lower accommodation → higher depression at one and three

So if you’re avoidant, don’t mistake early numbness for healing. The distress may simply be waiting to surface.

Busting the Avoidance Coping Myth

One surprise: classic avoidance coping (distraction, denial) didn’t significantly explain distress when all coping types were analysed together.

The heavy hitters were still:

  • Self-punishment (bad)
  • Accommodation (good)

So, being “busy” only helps if you’re actively reframing and creating replacement habits. Otherwise, you’re just running on empty.

What To Actually Do

Here are three actionable experiments:

  1. Catch & Replace: Every time you catch a self-blaming thought, write down one small action you’ll do in the next hour (walk, call a friend, cook dinner).
  2. Acceptance Script: Write a three-line statement acknowledging the breakup. Read it daily: “This hurts, and I can heal. I’m choosing to build new routines.”
  3. Replacement Habits: Add one new routine each week — gym class, journaling, evening walk — to rebuild a secure rhythm.

The Takeaway

Your attachment style shapes tendencies.
Your coping strategies shape outcomes.

As the study authors concluded: “Findings highlight coping strategies as potential intervention targets to promote the recovery of emerging adults experiencing breakup distress”

So next time you’re spiralling into “I’m just anxious/avoidant,” pause. Ask:

👉 What’s the next helpful action I can take in the next hour?

That’s the dial you can turn today.